Repair vs. Capital Improvement: A Landlord's Tax Guide for Jacksonville Rentals

You bought a 1940s bungalow in Murray Hill to flip. Or maybe you own a multi-unit rental in Riverside, managing tenants and timelines. You're tracking expenses diligently in a spreadsheet. This month, you replaced a tenant's water heater, repainted three rooms after a move-out, and finally hired a crew to put a new roof on the building.

Now, you stare at your Excel file, and a knot tightens in your stomach.

Is that $1,200 water heater a "repair," deductible in full this year? Or is it a "capital improvement," an expense you have to spread out, or depreciate, over 27.5 years? What about the paint? What about the $15,000 roof?

This confusion is more than a bookkeeping headache. It's the difference between a healthy tax deduction this year and a minor one. It’s also the line between a clean, audit-proof tax return and one that could trigger an expensive IRS inquiry.

Many Jacksonville investors, both new and experienced, get this wrong. They misclassify expenses and either overpay their taxes (hurting their cash flow) or underpay them (risking penalties and interest).

The distinction is critical. Let's clear it up.

Understanding the IRS View: Maintain vs. Enhance

The Internal Revenue Service looks at your expenses through a specific lens. It wants to know the purpose of the money you spent. Was it to maintain your property's current condition, or was it to enhance it?

Repairs are current expenses. The IRS defines a repair as an action that keeps your property in a good, ordinary operating condition. It doesn't add significantly to the property's value or extend its useful life. It just fixes a problem.

Think of it as routine maintenance. Examples include:

• Fixing a leaky faucet.
• Patching a small hole in the drywall.
• Replacing a broken window pane.
• Fixing a running toilet.

These are the costs of doing business as a landlord. You can deduct the full cost of these repairs in the tax year you paid for them.

Capital Improvements are long-term investments. These are expenses that add value to your property, prolong its life, or adapt it to a new use. Instead of deducting the cost all at once, you must "capitalize" it. This means you add the cost to your property's "basis" (the amount you've invested in it) and recover the cost over time through depreciation. For a residential rental property, that timeline is 27.5 years.

This is where the financial impact becomes clear. A $10,000 repair gives you a $10,000 deduction this year. A $10,000 improvement gives you only a $364 deduction this year ($10,000 / 27.5).

The Three-Part Test: Betterment, Adaptation, and Restoration

The IRS provides a framework to help you decide. An expense is a capital improvement if it results in a Betterment, an Adaptation, or a Restoration (known as the "BAR" test).

B for Betterment

An expense is a betterment if it fixes a pre-existing defect, materially adds to your property, or materially increases its capacity, strength, or quality.

• Example: You buy that Murray Hill flip knowing the foundation is cracked. Fixing that foundation is a betterment because you are correcting a defect that existed when you acquired the property.
• Example: You add a new deck to your Avondale rental. This is a material addition. It's an improvement.
• Example: You replace laminate countertops with granite. This is a material upgrade in quality. It's an improvement.

A for Adaptation

This is the most straightforward. An expense is an adaptation if it changes the property's intended use.

• Example: You convert the garage of your rental into a living space or an accessory dwelling unit (ADU).
• Example: You convert a single-family home into a duplex to house two separate tenants.

You are adapting the property to a new function. All associated costs are capital improvements.

R for Restoration

This is the trickiest category and where most investors get confused. An expense is a restoration if it "returns the property to a like-new condition" or replaces a major component of a system.

The IRS forces you to look at your property not as one single thing, but as a collection of "units of property." These include the building structure, the HVAC system, the plumbing system, the electrical system, and so on.

Replacing a major component or a substantial part of one of these systems is a restoration.

• Example: A full roof replacement. The roof is a major part of the building structure. Replacing it is a restoration.
• Example: Replacing all the wiring in the house. This restores the electrical system.
• Example: Replacing all the plumbing pipes. This restores the plumbing system.

Back to That Confusing Spreadsheet: Let's Classify Your Expenses

Let's apply these rules to the original list of expenses for your Jacksonville property.

1. Repainting Three Rooms

This is almost always a repair. Painting is considered routine maintenance. You are simply keeping the property in good, clean condition for the next tenant. You are not adding value or extending the building's life. You can deduct the full cost this year.

• The Exception: If the painting was part of a larger, new renovation (like a full kitchen remodel), the IRS would likely see it as part of that total capital improvement. But standalone painting is a repair.

2. Replacing a Water Heater

This is an improvement. A water heater is a major component of the building's plumbing system. By replacing the entire unit, you are performing a restoration of that system. You must add the $1,200 cost to your property's basis and depreciate it over 27.5 years.

• The Contrast: If you had called a plumber to simply repair the pilot light or replace a heating element on the existing water heater, that would have been a repair.

3. Putting on a New Roof

This is a classic capital improvement. A roof is a major, structural part of the building. A full replacement falls directly under the restoration rule. It significantly extends the life of the property. That $15,000 cost will be depreciated over 27.5 years.

• The Contrast: If a storm (like a hurricane or nor'easter) blew off a few shingles and you paid someone $500 to replace just those missing shingles, that would be a repair.

Making It Simpler: Two "Safe Harbors" You Should Know

The IRS understands these rules are complex. It created a few "safe harbors" to simplify life for small landlords.

• De Minimis Safe Harbor (DMSH): This is your best friend. If you don't have an "applicable financial statement" (which most small investors do not), you can elect to expense any item or invoice that costs $2,500 or less.
  • Think back to that $1,200 water heater. Under the main rules, it's an improvement. But under the De Minimis Safe Harbor, you can elect to treat it as a current-year expense because the invoice was less than $2,500. This is a powerful tool for improving your cash flow.
• Routine Maintenance Safe Harbor (RMSH): This allows you to expense activities you reasonably expect to perform more than once during the property's life. This covers preventative maintenance.
  • This provides another path for expensing that paint job. You fully expect to paint the interior more than once over the 27.5 years you own the property.

These safe harbors are elections you make with your tax preparer. You can't use them if your books aren't clean and organized.

Your Excel Sheet Is Not an Audit Defense

That spreadsheet you're using is a good tool for collecting data. But it is not a bookkeeping system.

It cannot tell you if an expense qualifies for the De Minimis Safe Harbor. It cannot distinguish a repair from a restoration. It cannot track your property's basis or calculate depreciation schedules.

Getting these classifications wrong has real consequences.

If you expense everything, you risk an IRS audit. If the agent reclassifies your $15,000 roof "repair" as an improvement, you will suddenly owe a significant amount of back tax, plus penalties and interest.

If you capitalize everything to "be safe," you are hurting yourself. You are paying more tax than you need to, crippling your current-year cash flow and letting the government hold your money interest-free for decades.

This is the value of professional bookkeeping. A good bookkeeper's job isn't just data entry. It's classification. It's about building a clean, accurate, and defensible set of books month by month. When your records are organized, you can clearly see what you spent and why. This makes tax season infinitely smoother for your CPA and provides the necessary backup in the event of an audit.

Stop guessing and hoping you got it right. A real estate portfolio is a business. It's time to treat it like one.

‍